« January 2011 | Main | April 2011 »

Rob Bell - Love Wins. Shooting our own troops or defending the truth?

Images-1

In the last few years many Christians have enjoyed and been challenged by the Pastor of Mars Hill through his books such as Velvet Elvis, Sex God or Drops Like Stars or hearing on one of his tours or podcasts. I saw him a few years ago in Cardiff. He was pretty interesting.
Last night as I was preparing to begin a Street Pastor shift I could see a significant number of people getting worked up on twitter about his latest book, Love Wins. I think one of the interesting things about how the Christian grapevine works and the speed of social media is that this torrent of comment is comment is even before the book has been released!
The starting point of the controversy appears to be release of the description by his publisher Harper Collins. It Reads:
Fans flock to his Facebook page, his NOOMA videos have been viewed by millions, and his Sunday sermons are attended by 10,000 parishioners—with a downloadable podcast reaching 50,000 more. An electrifying, unconventional pastor whom Time magazine calls “a singular rock star in the church world,” Rob Bell is the most vibrant, central religious leader of the millennial generation. Now, in Love Wins: Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived, Bell addresses one of the most controversial issues of faith—the afterlife—arguing that a loving God would never sentence human souls to eternal suffering. With searing insight, Bell puts hell on trial, and his message is decidedly optimistic—eternal life doesn’t start when we die; it starts right now. And ultimately, Love Wins.
Unknown This was picked up by Justin Taylor on his blog site. Who whilst says he is reluctant to judge Bell's theology based upon a release written by an authors publisher then proceeds to pretty much make the judgement anyway. This was picked up by Mark Driscoll who retweeted the link. His popularity took the retweets to a whole new level! Cue the opportunity for tons of Christians to way in. Then John Piper weighed in with a tweet that said "farewell Rob Bell..." and linked to Taylor's site.
The central concern seems to be that Rob Bell may say that hell is empty because a loving God  would not send His children to Hell. This theology is called universalism and you would struggle to find any evangelical to buy into to this as it very difficult, if not impossible to sustain if you read what the bible says about heaven and hell. Let me be clear I can find no evidence to support universalism. However, I am in no position to condemn Bell's theology in this area as at this point I do not know what it is. I think he is right that how we view heaven and hell is fundamentally important. I also think what Christians believe and express, affects how people who do not share our faith, react.
I watched Bell's trailer film for the new book (posted below) and I think he is typically enigmatic within it. I guess this is to encourage us to buy the book. So I am intrigued, I am curious and ultimately I am interested enough to buy the book.
At this point the thing that is REALLY interesting to me is why on rumour, hear say, half information and gossip Christian leaders, lay people, church celebrities and those less well known are already getting hot under the collar. Is the excuse they have been waiting for to attack Bell? Do they enjoy picking the theological log out the eyes of others? Do they court controversy (as perhaps Bell does)? Are they just causing trouble? I am not sure, I will leave you to decide. However, I am reminded of a quote the Rob Parsons once shared with me "the Christian army is the only one that enjoys shooting its own troops".
Please understand I think it is important to defend truth but I think its important to know what someone else believes before you attack them!
 


Cardiff Street Pastors At Risk As Funding Is Cut

This is the statement that we issued to the press today. Already we are seeing some interest.

 

Index-4-sp-up Street Pastors beacon about to be extinguished?

 

ONE of the beacons of Cardiff’s weekend night life could be extinguished through lack of funding.

The city’s faithful band of Street Pastors have been familiar to late night visitors for more than two years.

Drinkers in the town centre clubs and pubs have made use of the patrolling Street Pastors for everything from helping them find a taxi home to putting flip flops on their bare or battered feet.

But funding to ensure the work continues runs out next month and so the Street Pastors will not be able to continue beyond March.

 “Like everyone, we’re feeling the economic pinch,” explained Gary Smith, who runs Cardiff Street Pastors.

 “Our statutory funding runs out next month and although we do a lot of fundraising to support the work ourselves, the shortfall is too significant to allow us to continue.

 “As things stand we will be running our last patrols next month because we have no funds guaranteed to see us beyond then.

 “It really is a huge shame because we believe we’ve done a significant work to help reduce crime on our city centre streets and to help improve the tarnished image of our capital.”

 That is a view echoed by the partners, including South Wales Police and local business owners, who work with the Street Pastors during the busy weekend evenings.

 Ahead of the Black Friday event in December, Inspector Tony Bishop said:  “As the Inspector responsible for policing Cardiff city centre, I can say from experience that the Street Pastor’s presence and assistance to South Wales Police in managing the night time economy each and every weekend is invaluable.

 “The Street Pastors provide a very reassuring presence and dealing with victims and potential victims of crime in a very caring & professional manner has a significant and positive impact on those individuals who are at times very vulnerable because of their circumstances, normally because they have had too much to drink.

“South Wales Police manage the night time economy through a partnership approach & the Street Pastors are a very vital part of that team here in Cardiff city centre.”

DSCF0271 There are more than forty trained Street Pastors in Cardiff, and there are a number of volunteers currently waiting for their accreditation.

 “Criminologists say when people are in danger then what they need is capable guardians. That’s what Street Pastors are,” said Gary Smith.

 “In Wales’ capital city we believe we play a vital role and we have no shortage of people wanting to help, what we are lacking is the funding to ensure we can continue delivering the service and accountability we have done up to now.”

 

Ends

 

 

Notes for Editors:

The Street Pastors are accountable to the police and local authority as well as the Welsh Assembly Government.

 

Cardiff Street Pastors were funded by the Home Office previously, but funding has been cut across the board.

 

There is no statutory funding available to date and because of the nature of the work the service cannot be mothballed, hence notice will have to be given to terminate the street patrols from the end of March.

 

The Street Pastors are on the streets of Cardiff on a Friday and Saturday night from 22:00 – 04:00.

 

During nights where major events are held, such as the student night Carnage, the Street Pastors give up an additional night to their usual Friday and Saturday in order to help support the emergency services to ensure safety in the city.

 

In the last year, 15 new recruits have joined the original team as they seek to support those in need of their help after a night out.

 

The Street Pastors have given out over 3,000 pairs of flip flops and 2,500 bottles of water.

 

Gary Smith is available for interview on 07782 305738.